Hi Eric -
Thanks for the quick reply. Sounds complicated. The task list is the same for every project so I have that going for me. It is all copied over from a Template each time a new project is added. Even better, the users who are assigned these tasks never change. Task 1 is always "task a" assigned to "michelle" for example.
Currently, the way the report is setup to show % complete is working as is. Looking at the photo I attached, Danya will not start on a task unless % complete is equal to 25%. She knows if it shows 0%, that Michelle still needs to complete her task. It works but is not as visually appealing and it still takes a tiny bit of thought to comprehend. Our users are 100% capable of doing this, I'm just a sucker for icons these days and thought there might be an easy way to reflect those percentages as icons so to speak.
In writing this response I may have thought of an idea. I will update if it works. :)